Status update and outlook

Message boards : Malaria Control : Status update and outlook

Author Message
Profile maire
Volunteer moderator
Project administrator
Project developer
Project scientist
Send message
Joined: Nov 7 05
Posts: 438
Credit: 118,258
RAC: 0

Dear malariacontrol.net user,

As you have read in our latest status update, we are close to the end of the current phase of the project. We will soon stop sending out workunits for a few weeks, until the project scientists have prepared the input data for the next phase of research.

Update: We have stopped creating new workunits on Mon March 1st

This is a good time to explain what we have achieved with your help over the last few months, and how these results will be used in the future.

Work to Date
The main objective of this phase of the project was to optimize our mathematical models, to get them to predict the malaria situation in the field as accurately as possible. We use an �evolutionary� approach: Starting with an initial version of the model, we create a range of variations. Then we test all the variations against the real-world data to see which perform best. We then take the best-performing variations and repeat the process, over and over again... While extremely effective, this approach takes a great deal of computation; we couldn�t do it without your help.

By way of illustration, here's a chart of results from one of our recent runs: You can see how our measure of the discrepancy between model and real world (on the y-axis) decreases as the model is optimized through successive iterations (on the x-axis).



Another way of looking at the same data is by plotting the predicted outcomes of the model against real-world data. The following examples look at one outcome, the so-called age-incidence of malaria episodes: This is the rate at which humans of a certain age come down with malaria. Here it is shown as the number of episodes per person-year (py). The first of the two plots show an early stage of the �evolution� process, where field data and predictions are quite different. In the second image, plotted from a later stage, you can see the data and predictions converge: thus indicating that the model has become much more accurate.





If you're wondering what Ndiop and Dielmo means, these are the names of two Senegalese villages, that's where the field studies for this particular dataset were carried out.

Moving Forward
We�ve gone through this type of evolutionary optimization process with quite a number of different model formulations. In technical terms, we have �parameterized a number of different models�. Some of these did not do a good job at predicting patterns like the age-incidence curves above, and we've abandoned these, the rest were kept in our growing model family. As a result, we now have a set of models which work in very different ways but which all appear effective. This gives us a strong basis from which to undertake the next phase of our project. The goal is to now compare the predicted impact of various control interventions (such as bed nets, indoor spraying, vaccines, case management,etc.) across our current families such model formulations. This is a way of learning about model uncertainties, and is done routinely these days with climate models.

The following -very preliminary- plots demonstrate where this is going: We have simulated an effective house spraying program that went on for twelve years and then stopped. We've then plotted the predictions from such a model ensemble (Prevalence, shown on the Y-axis, indicates the proportion of the human population with parasites in their blood):





One of our top priorities in the near future will be the design and analysis of more simulation experiments like this one, predicting the effect of a number of different malaria control interventions. Once optimized-- though your contributions-- these models can be used to develop intelligent and effective deployment strategies, hopefully saving a great many lives.

Thank you for your ongoing interest and support!

On behalf of the modeling team,
Nick
____________
Nicolas Maire
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute
http://www.swisstph.ch

AnRM
Send message
Joined: Mar 7 06
Posts: 54
Credit: 2,130,571
RAC: 0

Very interesting, Nick. Thanks for the update. It's great to see some results!
____________

Aleksander Parkitny
Send message
Joined: Nov 21 07
Posts: 2
Credit: 50,703
RAC: 0

Here is the polish translation.

http://www.boincatpoland.org/wiki/1_marca_2010_Malariacontrol.net_zako%C5%84czy%C5%82a_kolejny_etap_bada%C5%84

If You have any other texts to translate :D feel free to contact me

troll81(this-silly-sign-looking-like-a-letter-A)poczta.onet.pl

Profile maire
Volunteer moderator
Project administrator
Project developer
Project scientist
Send message
Joined: Nov 7 05
Posts: 438
Credit: 118,258
RAC: 0

Thanks for the feedback, and the translation!

I'd like to take the opportunity to thank Matt Blumberg from gridrepublic for his input, which greatly helped make this update more readable.
Nick
____________
Nicolas Maire
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute
http://www.swisstph.ch

PvB
Send message
Joined: Aug 16 09
Posts: 1
Credit: 15,241
RAC: 0

Wow! It's great to see that the crunching really helps in the fight against malaria.
This motivates me even more to keep MalariaControl in my BOINC project-list.

In my opinion, the following things might help in attracting more crunchers and/or keeping existing crunchers on-board:
- keep the runtime for workunits as small as possible (I think most ppl like a lot of small workunits better than 1 large workunit which runs forever);
- make sure you have a nice screensaver (ppl wanna see what their computer is doing!)

Thank you very much for your very clear explanation of the achievements, Nicolas!

Kind Regards,

PvB

AmigaForever
Send message
Joined: Jan 13 07
Posts: 11
Credit: 45,309
RAC: 82

Thank you very much for this update on the project and its results! it's nice to see some of the progress :)


BTW, while you update the components of your new model, could you maybe take a look on the graphics shown in BOINC, too? After the BOINC core changed it does not work since, as described and discussed already here:

https://malariacontrol.net/forum_thread.php?id=545

Maybe if you can spare some time, it was a nice feature.


Anyway, many thanks + greetings to the whole team :)

AmigaForever
Send message
Joined: Jan 13 07
Posts: 11
Credit: 45,309
RAC: 82

BTW, while you update the components of your new model, could you maybe take a look on the graphics shown in BOINC, too? After the BOINC core changed it does not work since, as described and discussed already here:

https://malariacontrol.net/forum_thread.php?id=545

Maybe if you can spare some time, it was a nice feature.


I just got a few workunits and found that you already did fix the graphics.


THANK YOU GUYS!
:D


Post to thread

Message boards : Malaria Control : Status update and outlook


Return to malariacontrol.net main page


Copyright © 2013 africa@home